id stringlengths 31 31 | text stringlengths 859 9.09k | family stringclasses 1
value | kind stringclasses 6
values | source stringclasses 44
values | court stringclasses 57
values | gold stringlengths 365 1.02k | presentation stringclasses 3
values | group_id stringlengths 31 37 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
cap_panel_vote-518008833a904d4b | You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Passage:
The State ex rel. Riser Foods, Inc., f.k.a. American Seaway Foods, Inc., Appellant, v. Trim... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:ohio-st-3d | Supreme Court of Ohio | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["Cook", "Moyer", "Resnick", "Wright", "Sweeney", "Douglas", "Pfeifer"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": ["Resnick"], "vote": "6–1", "yes": ["Cook", "Douglas", "Moyer", "Pfeifer", "Sweeney", "Wright"], "types": ["m... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:1737309|1737385 |
cap_panel_vote-05dcbd5d07f5e281 | [Task]
Here is part of a court decision with more than one judge. Work out the answer from the text. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out. Rely only on the passage.
<text>
Robert L. KNIGHT, as Executor of the Estate of H. E. Knight, al... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:so2d | Florida Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["DREW"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["DREW", "TERRELL", "O’CONNELL", "ROBERTS", "THORNAL"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": ["DREW"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["O’CONNELL", "ROBERTS", "TERRELL", "THORNAL"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "ques... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:9895513|9901405 |
cap_panel_vote-fcde8ac49eae331a | Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question about the court's members. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Answer these in order.
1. Name any dissenting judges.
2. Yes or no: did DREW join the opinion of the court?
Text:
Paul L.... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:so2d | Florida Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["DREW", "TERRELL", "O’CONNELL", "ROBERTS", "THORNAL"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "THORNAL", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["DREW", "O’CONNELL", "ROBERTS", "TERRELL"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:9895513|9901405 |
cap_panel_vote-11ec1503753f88eb | Use the case excerpt to answer the question about who decided the case and how they voted. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Did the court's decision draw a dissent?
Text:
333 P.2d 1051
George E. JOHNSTON, Appellant, v. BOARD OF EDUCATION... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:nm | Supreme Court of New Mexico | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["LUJAN", "SADLER", "McGHEE", "COMPTON", "SHILLINGLAW"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SADLER", "dissenters": ["SHILLINGLAW"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["COMPTON", "LUJAN", "McGHEE"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:2844738|2846070 |
cap_panel_vote-cf87cecea1ab3b49 | <|start|><|user|>
Look at the opinion text and answer. Omitted text is marked [...]. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. A judge who concurs is not a dissenter.
Text:
E. E. PASCHEN, Petitioner, v. RATLIFF CITY TRUCKING COMPANY, State Insurance... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:p2d | Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["BACON", "BOYDSTON", "BRIGHTMIRE"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BOYDSTON", "dissenters": ["BRIGHTMIRE"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["BACON"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Is there a dissenting judge ... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10437874|10439506 |
cap_panel_vote-2989d06c9a64ec26 | You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...]. Keep the answer short.
Questions:
1. Is there a dissenting judge in this case?
2. What was the vote?
3. ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:p2d | Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["BACON", "BRIGHTMIRE", "BOYDSTON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BACON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["BOYDSTON", "BRIGHTMIRE"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Is there a dissenting judge ... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10437874|10439506 |
cap_panel_vote-3760493d0280072b | ### Task
Below are the head matter and the opening of each opinion in a reported case. Answer the question. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
---
The State, ex rel. Beacon Journal Publishing Company, Appellant and Cross-Appellee, v. Ohio Dep... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:ohio-st-3d | Supreme Court of Ohio | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "5–2", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["Moyer", "Brown", "Sweeney", "Douglas", "Wright", "Holmes", "Resnick"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "Wright", "dissenters": ["Douglas", "Sweeney"], "vote": "5–2", "yes": ["Brown", "Holmes", "Moyer", "Resnick"], "types": ["majori... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:1424181|1424162 |
cap_panel_vote-0a0e6cc5566c9302 | <|start|><|user|>
Look at the opinion text and answer. Omitted text is marked [...]. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
Give the vote of the court (for–against).
Excerpt:
The State, ex rel. Grandview Hospital and Medical Center, Ap... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:ohio-st-3d | Supreme Court of Ohio | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "7–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["Moyer", "Brown", "Resnick", "Sweeney", "Douglas", "Wright", "Holmes"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": [], "vote": "7–0", "yes": ["Brown", "Douglas", "Holmes", "Moyer", "Resnick", "Sweeney", "Wright"], "types": [... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:1424181|1424162 |
cap_panel_vote-7cc3000c59c44191 | Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Example 1
Text:
419 A.2d 588
Moe Henry HANKIN, Sabina Hankin, Gertrude Hankin, Perch P. Hankin, Benjamin R. Shanken and Pauline Shanken v. Ronald... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["POLLEY", "SHERWOOD", "BURCH", "CAMPBELL", "BROWN"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BURCH", "dissenters": ["POLLEY"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["BROWN", "CAMPBELL", "SHERWOOD"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join",... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:4715116|4713312 |
cap_panel_vote-31c2c92710524f14 | Read the excerpts from this appellate decision and answer the question about the judges. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. Keep the answer short.
<text>
VON SEGGERN BROS. & LUDDEN, Respondents, vs. ANTELOPE COUNTY STATE BANK, et al, Appellan... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["POLLEY", "SHERWOOD", "BURCH", "CAMPBELL", "BROWN"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BROWN", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["BURCH", "POLLEY", "SHERWOOD"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join", "q": "Did... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:4715116|4713312 |
cap_panel_vote-2bcd4acd56df09d4 | Answer the question about the panel, using only the text provided. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...]. Keep the answer short.
Answer these in order.
1. Yes or no: did MOISE join the opinion of the court?
2. Who, if anyone, dissented from the... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:nm | Supreme Court of New Mexico | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["NOBLE", "MOISE", "CARMODY", "CHAVEZ", "COMPTON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "CARMODY", "dissenters": ["MOISE"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["CHAVEZ", "COMPTON", "NOBLE"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:2805522|2808383 |
cap_panel_vote-b42d5bc202ac37b0 | Instruction: Here is part of a court decision with more than one judge. Work out the answer from the text. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...].
```
419 P.2d 253
Fred W. ROBINSON, Petitioner, v. Harold A. COX, Warden of the New Mexico State Penitent... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:nm | Supreme Court of New Mexico | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["NOBLE", "MOISE", "CHAVEZ", "CARMODY", "COMPTON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "NOBLE", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["CARMODY", "CHAVEZ", "COMPTON", "MOISE"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join", "... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:2805522|2808383 |
cap_panel_vote-f8a1cd00b150fed3 | <|start|><|user|>
Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question about the court's members. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. Do not use outside knowledge of the court.
Answer these in order.
1. Who dissented?
2. Yes or no: did O’BR... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["DROWOTA"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["BIRCH", "DROWOTA", "REID", "ANDERSON", "O’BRIEN"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "REID", "dissenters": ["DROWOTA"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["ANDERSON", "BIRCH", "O’BRIEN"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10016783|10013723 |
cap_panel_vote-3d22f67e8034a34f | Answer the question about the panel, using only the text provided. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...]. Give surnames as they are printed.
Who dissented?
Passage:
In the MATTER OF the ESTATE OF Mark E. SNYDER, Deceased. Catherine J. SNYDER, Plaint... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:sw2d | Missouri Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["PUDLOWSKI", "KAROHL", "SIMON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "PUDLOWSKI", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["KAROHL", "SIMON"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_dissent", "q": "Who dissented?", "answer": [... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10016783|10013723 |
cap_panel_vote-9743d8e125e7c5bc | Request: From the court record below, determine the answer. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
Text:
BROADMOOR-KINGSPORT APARTMENTS, INC., and Broadmoor-Kingsport Associates, Appellees, v. STATE of Tennessee and John K. King, Commissione... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["BROCK", "FONES", "COOPER", "DROWOTA", "HARBISON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "COOPER", "dissenters": ["DROWOTA"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["BROCK", "FONES", "HARBISON"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:9959704|9973506 |
cap_panel_vote-0a1bcfdc1dc679b6 | <|start|><|system|>
You are a helpful assistant.<|eot|>
<|user|>
Using the excerpts, answer the question about the opinions and the votes. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
Example 1
Text:
Reece L. SMITH, Jr., Petitioner, v. STATE... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sw2d | Missouri Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["GAERTNER", "PUDLOWSKI", "KAROHL"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "PUDLOWSKI", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["GAERTNER", "KAROHL"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join", "q": "Yes or no: did GAERTNER j... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9959704|9973506 |
cap_panel_vote-d0f62be622f35aac | Answer using the case text that follows. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...]. Give surnames as they are printed.
Text:
Joseph E. CORCORAN, Appellant (Plaintiff below), v. STATE of Indiana, Appellee (Defendant below).
No. 02S00-0508-PD-350.
Supreme ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ne2d | Supreme Court of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["RUCKER"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["BOEHM", "SULLIVAN", "DICKSON", "SHEPARD", "RUCKER"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SULLIVAN", "dissenters": ["RUCKER"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["BOEHM", "DICKSON", "SHEPARD"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind":... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:8425929|8426026 |
cap_panel_vote-7f732c3e9e897691 | <|start|><|user|>
Answer the question about the opinions filed in this case and the judges who decided it. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Answer each question.
1. List the judges who dissented, if any.
2. Is there a dissenting judge in th... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ne2d | Supreme Court of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["BOEHM", "SULLIVAN", "DICKSON", "SHEPARD", "RUCKER"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SHEPARD", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["BOEHM", "DICKSON", "RUCKER", "SULLIVAN"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_di... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:8425929|8426026 |
cap_panel_vote-232f2fd3de9ed5ab | Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
Give the vote of the court (for–against).
```
BANK OF KIRKSVILLE, Respondent-Appellant, v. Jimmie SMALL, Appellant-Respondent.
No. 69148.
Sup... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sw2d | Supreme Court of Missouri | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "6–1", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["BILLINGS", "WELLIYER", "ROBERTSON", "HIGGINS", "DONNELLY", "RENDLEN", "BLACKMAR"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "RENDLEN", "dissenters": ["DONNELLY"], "vote": "6–1", "yes": ["BILLINGS", "BLACKMAR", "HIGGINS", "ROBERTSON", "WELLI... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:9962988|9975901 |
cap_panel_vote-ec3654ba04eeb1b4 | <|start|><|user|>
Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question about the court's members. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out. Keep the answer short.
```
Lonnie SNELLING, Appellant-Plaintiff, v. John BOSTON, Respondent-Defe... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sw2d | Missouri Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "3–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["SIMON", "CRANDALL", "GRIMM"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SIMON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["CRANDALL", "GRIMM"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_vote", "q": "Give the vote of the court (for–aga... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9962988|9975901 |
cap_panel_vote-c0f68b8b9dbb1914 | Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out. Give surnames as they are printed.
Did the court's decision draw a dissent?
<text>
Robert H. ROBERTS, et al., Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["BROCK", "FONES", "COOPER", "DRO-WOTA", "HARBISON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "HARBISON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["BROCK", "COOPER", "DRO-WOTA", "FONES"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", ... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:9985052|9972616 |
cap_panel_vote-95003246eddf7d3e | <|start|><|user|>
Look at the opinion text and answer. Omitted text is marked [...]. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...]. Do not use outside knowledge of the court.
Name any dissenting judges.
```
20414
William N. COLYER and Arnet Lewis, App... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:sc | Supreme Court of South Carolina | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["Lewis"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["Rhodes", "Ness", "Gregory", "Lewis", "Littlejohn"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "Ness", "dissenters": ["Lewis"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["Gregory", "Littlejohn", "Rhodes"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:2138362|2138361 |
cap_panel_vote-a1da4a3ffffb9583 | Answer using the case text that follows. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
What was the vote split in this decision?
Passage:
I.A.J. v. STATE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES.
2980634.
Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama.
Sept. 3, 1999.
Reh... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "4–1", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["MONROE", "YATES", "THOMPSON", "ROBERTSON", "CRAWLEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "YATES", "dissenters": ["CRAWLEY"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["MONROE", "ROBERTSON", "THOMPSON"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:11120685|11113385 |
cap_panel_vote-64fc7b745d1f28f2 | [Task]
Answer using the case text that follows. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. Keep the answer short.
Excerpt:
ANN CORPORATION et al. v. AEROSTAR WORLD, INC.
2990726.
Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama.
Sept. 29, 2000.
Gene Spencer, Dothan... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "5–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["YATES", "MONROE", "THOMPSON", "ROBERTSON", "CRAWLEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MONROE", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["CRAWLEY", "ROBERTSON", "THOMPSON", "YATES"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "p... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:11120685|11113385 |
cap_panel_vote-7e0464c5887906c5 | [Task]
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Answer these in order.
1. Did the court's decision draw a dissent?
2. What was the vote?
3. Yes or no: did HEFLIN join the opinion of the... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:ala | Alabama Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["SHORES", "MERRILL", "HEFLIN", "JONES", "MADDOX"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "JONES", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["HEFLIN", "MADDOX", "MERRILL", "SHORES"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q":... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:2545219|2543006 |
cap_panel_vote-f0e7618bba1e4a02 | <|start|><|user|>
Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
<text>
James Michael THOMPSON, Jr., et al. v. Dayna M. CASE.
2000357.
Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama.
Aug. 2... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["YATES", "PITTMAN", "THOMPSON", "CRAWLEY", "MURDOCK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MURDOCK", "dissenters": ["PITTMAN"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["CRAWLEY", "THOMPSON", "YATES"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"ki... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9132487|9240214 |
cap_panel_vote-78af565b82d8f4d3 | <|start|><|user|>
Use the case excerpt to answer the question about who decided the case and how they voted. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...]. Rely only on the passage.
Example 1
Text:
In re RULES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA RELATI... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["YATES", "PITTMAN", "THOMPSON", "CRAWLEY", "MURDOCK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "THOMPSON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["CRAWLEY", "MURDOCK", "PITTMAN", "YATES"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9132487|9240214 |
cap_panel_vote-f4013ef155e55bcc | Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...]. Rely only on the passage.
Excerpt:
Donna DYRKOPP, Petitioner, v. The INDUSTRIAL CLAIM APPEALS OFFICE of the State of Colorado; Denver School District ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:p3d | Colorado Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["NIETO", "NEY", "MARQUEZ"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "NEY", "dissenters": ["MARQUEZ"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["NIETO"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Did any judge dissent?", "answer"... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:9491362|9491149 |
cap_panel_vote-d06ee28bedd5bfb4 | <|start|><|user|>
Answer the question about the panel, using only the text provided. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
"""
BRUSH GROCERY KART, INC., a Colorado corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. SURE FINE MARKET, INC., a Colorado corpora... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:p3d | Colorado Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["NIETO", "NEY", "MARQUEZ"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "NIETO", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["MARQUEZ", "NEY"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Did any judge dissent?", "answer": "no", "ju... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9491362|9491149 |
cap_panel_vote-8e022db7fa32058f | <|start|><|user|>
Read the excerpts from this appellate decision and answer the question about the judges. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Which members of the court disagreed with the decision?
```
Michael D. COLLINS, Appellant-Defenda... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["BAILEY"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["SULLIVAN", "MATHIAS", "BAILEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SULLIVAN", "dissenters": ["BAILEY"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["MATHIAS"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_dissent", "q": "Which me... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:8959201|8950784 |
cap_panel_vote-af3186c4741e1dd9 | Look at the opinion text and answer. Omitted text is marked [...]. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Excerpt:
Alonzo HIGGINBOTHAM, Appellant-Defendant, v. STATE of Indiana, Appellee-Plaintiff.
No. 49A02-0404-CR-342.
Court of Appeals of India... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["SULLIVAN", "MATHIAS", "BAILEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MATHIAS", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["BAILEY", "SULLIVAN"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_dissent", "q": "Which members of the court... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:8959201|8950784 |
cap_panel_vote-51c1e1fb1a05fbe3 | You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
"""
In re the MARRIAGE OF Larry HOFFNER, Appellee, and Mary M. Hoffner, Appellant.
No. 88C... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:p2d | Colorado Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "2–1", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["HUME", "TURSI", "PIERCE"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "PIERCE", "dissenters": ["TURSI"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["HUME"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_vote", "q": "How did the judges divide? Give... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10388332|10384266 |
cap_panel_vote-ca452c8db6e2760d | <|start|><|system|>
Answer accurately and concisely.<|eot|>
<|user|>
Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Text:
ST. VINCENT’S HOSPITAL and State Compensation Insuranc... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:p2d | Colorado Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "3–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["SMITH", "REED", "HODGES"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "HODGES", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["REED", "SMITH"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_vote", "q": "How did the judges divide? Give the vote ... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10388332|10384266 |
cap_panel_vote-c5cc9980e2d9c52e | <|start|><|user|>
You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...]. Rely only on the passage.
```
Robert TIPTON, Appellant-Petitioner, v. STATE o... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["RILEY", "MATHIAS", "BROOK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BROOK", "dissenters": ["RILEY"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["MATHIAS"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Was there a dissent in this c... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9446553|9453275 |
cap_panel_vote-857c74456f547b05 | <|start|><|user|>
Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. Keep the answer short.
Excerpt:
Wayne KING, D.M.D., a/k/a William Waymon King, III, and Wayne King, D.M.D., P.C.,... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["RILEY", "MATHIAS", "BROOK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MATHIAS", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["BROOK", "RILEY"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Was there a dissent in this case?", "ans... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:9446553|9453275 |
cap_panel_vote-058dd19129afc23f | <|start|><|user|>
Below are the head matter and the opening of each opinion in a reported case. Answer the question. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
<text>
Johnny Carl HORTON, Appellant, v. STATE of Oklahoma, Appellee.
No. F-85-161.
Cour... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:p2d | Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["BRETT", "PARKS", "BUSSEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "BUSSEY", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["BRETT", "PARKS"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_any", "q": "Was there a dissent in this case?", "answe... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10414591|10424298 |
cap_panel_vote-bc68a0a232565762 | Here is part of a court decision with more than one judge. Work out the answer from the text. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...].
Excerpt:
Harold J. GUTHMILLER, Claimant and Appellant, v. SOUTH DAKOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, Employer and App... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:nw2d | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["SABERS", "HENDERSON", "AMUNDSON", "WUEST", "MILLER"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "HENDERSON", "dissenters": ["SABERS"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["AMUNDSON", "MILLER", "WUEST"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"ki... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10647602|10641596 |
cap_panel_vote-68852fa753089ef7 | <|start|><|user|>
Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
Passage:
Zelma M. MOE, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. Wallace E. MOE, Defendant and Appellee.
17627.
Supreme Co... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:nw2d | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["WUEST", "AMUNDSON", "SABERS", "HENDERSON", "MILLER"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MILLER", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["AMUNDSON", "HENDERSON", "SABERS", "WUEST"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10647602|10641596 |
cap_panel_vote-9eecc458f5aa3669 | <|start|><|user|>
Use the case excerpt to answer the question about who decided the case and how they voted. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
"""
73 So.2d 912
Ex parte BURNS.
7 Div. 238.
Supreme Court of Alabama.
June 30, 1954.
Wilkinson ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ala | Alabama Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["LAWSON", "GOODWYN"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["STAKELY", "MERRILL", "GOODWYN", "LIVINGSTON", "CLAYTON", "SIMPSON", "LAWSON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "STAKELY", "dissenters": ["GOODWYN", "LAWSON"], "vote": "5–2", "yes": ["CLAYTON", "LIVINGSTON", "MERR... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:5253949|5255350 |
cap_panel_vote-af5b02b69872a0a8 | Instruction: Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
Passage:
74 So.2d 814
Harmon C. WILLIAMS v. WATER WORKS AND SANITARY SEWER BOARD OF MONTGOMERY.
3 Div. 707.
Supreme Court o... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ala | Alabama Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["STAKELY", "LIVINGSTON", "CLAYTON", "SIMPSON", "LAWSON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "LAWSON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["CLAYTON", "LIVINGSTON", "SIMPSON", "STAKELY"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind"... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:5253949|5255350 |
cap_panel_vote-9bca8f3332228db1 | Use the case excerpt to answer the question about who decided the case and how they voted. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...].
---
NORTH MIAMI, a municipal corporation, v. SEAWAY CORPORATION, a corporation.
9 So. (2nd) 705
En Banc
August 4, 1942
R... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:fla | Florida Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["CHAPMAN", "WHITFIELD", "ADAMS", "TERRELL", "THOMAS", "BROWN", "BUFORD"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "CHAPMAN", "dissenters": ["ADAMS", "THOMAS"], "vote": "5–2", "yes": ["BROWN", "BUFORD", "TERRELL", "WHITFIELD"], "types": ["maj... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:1970770|1970840 |
cap_panel_vote-881502a47fb20245 | Request: Read the excerpts from this appellate decision and answer the question about the judges. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
Excerpt:
GEORGE GUNDERSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA
9 So. (2nd) 562
En Banc
July 31, 1942
Rehearing Denie... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:fla | Florida Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["CHAPMAN", "WHITFIELD", "TERRELL", "BUFORD", "THOMAS", "ADAMS", "BROWN"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": [], "vote": "7–0", "yes": ["ADAMS", "BROWN", "BUFORD", "CHAPMAN", "TERRELL", "THOMAS", "WHITFIELD"], "types":... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:1970770|1970840 |
cap_panel_vote-5ad027f78b49c936 | Question: Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question about the court's members. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
---
RENEE GRIFFITH, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. BUTTE SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 1, CHARLES UGGETTI and JOHN METZ, D... | cap_panel_vote | pv_author | cap:mont | Montana Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_author", "anchor_answer": "COTTER", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["MORRIS", "LEAPHART", "COTTER", "NELSON", "McGRATH", "RICE", "WHEAT"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "COTTER", "dissenters": ["LEAPHART"], "vote": "6–1", "yes": ["McGRATH", "MORRIS", "NELSON", "RICE", "WHEAT"], "types": ["maj... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:7325991|7327293 |
cap_panel_vote-4c0465a587cfd760 | <|start|><|user|>
This is an excerpt from an appellate court's decision. Answer the question that follows. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Which judge authored the majority opinion?
```
JOHNNIE LEE FOSTON, Petitioner and Appellant, v. STA... | cap_panel_vote | pv_author | cap:mont | Montana Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_author", "anchor_answer": "MORRIS", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["MORRIS", "COTTER", "NELSON", "McGRATH", "WHEAT"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "MORRIS", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["COTTER", "McGRATH", "NELSON", "WHEAT"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_aut... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:7325991|7327293 |
cap_panel_vote-c197977b79dd34c4 | Answer the question about the panel, using only the text provided. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...]. Give surnames as they are printed.
Did PIVARNIK side with the majority?
<text>
Richey Wayne PEAVLER, Appellant (Plaintiff Below), v. B... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:ne2d | Supreme Court of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["GIVAN", "DeBRULER", "DICKSON", "SHEPARD", "PIVARNIK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "SHEPARD", "dissenters": ["PIVARNIK"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["DeBRULER", "DICKSON", "GIVAN"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10905933|10926786 |
cap_panel_vote-6ff422bc0decc2f8 | Answer the question about the opinions filed in this case and the judges who decided it. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
"""
Michael DANIELS, Appellant, v. STATE of Indiana, Appellee.
No. 49S00-8601-PC-33.
Supreme Court of Indiana.
Se... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:ne2d | Supreme Court of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["GIVAN", "DeBRULER", "DICKSON", "SHEPARD", "PIVARNIK"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "DeBRULER", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["DICKSON", "GIVAN", "PIVARNIK", "SHEPARD"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "p... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10905933|10926786 |
cap_panel_vote-ebe8ef85776afa89 | <|start|><|user|>
Using the excerpts, answer the question about the opinions and the votes. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
"""
Karen Jonita Burton FINKENBINDER and Michael Finkenbinder v. Larry Eugene BURTON.
Civ. 3975.
Court of Civil App... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["WRIGHT", "HOLMES", "BRADLEY"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "WRIGHT", "dissenters": ["HOLMES"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["BRADLEY"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join", "q": "Yes or no: did HOLMES jo... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:7632691|7613575 |
cap_panel_vote-a15221b1ee956d34 | <|start|><|system|>
Answer accurately and concisely.<|eot|>
<|user|>
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text. A judge who concurs is not a dissenter.
```
HUDSON INDUSTRIES and Hudson Tran... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:so2d | Alabama Court of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["WRIGHT", "BRADLEY", "HOLMES"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "WRIGHT", "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["BRADLEY", "HOLMES"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join", "q": "Yes or no: did HOLMES join the op... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:7632691|7613575 |
cap_panel_vote-f949c683a16294a4 | Instruction: Look at the opinion text and answer. Omitted text is marked [...]. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Example 1
Text:
Wayne KING, D.M.D., a/k/a William Waymon King, III, and Wayne King, D.M.D., P.C., Appellants-Defendants, v. ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ohio-app-3d | Ohio Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": ["Koehler"], "unanimous": false, "panel": ["Koehler", "Hendrickson", "Jones"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "Hendrickson", "dissenters": ["Koehler"], "vote": "2–1", "yes": ["Jones"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_dissent", "q": "Whi... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:6712403|6712030 |
cap_panel_vote-b276ec24afc6b9e7 | Use the case excerpt to answer the question about who decided the case and how they voted. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
---
Giglio, Appellee, v. Doherty, Appellant.
(No. CA88-03-032
Decided October 11, 1988.)
Holbrock & Jonson, George N... | cap_panel_vote | pv_dissent | cap:ohio-app-3d | Ohio Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "pv_dissent", "anchor_answer": [], "unanimous": true, "panel": ["Koehler", "Hendrickson", "Jones"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": [], "vote": "3–0", "yes": ["Hendrickson", "Jones", "Koehler"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_dissent", "q": "Which members of... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:6712403|6712030 |
cap_panel_vote-fb4d9f6ff477435c | ### Task
Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out. Do not use outside knowledge of the court.
```
Rickie J. WALLEN, Petitioner-Appellant, v. STATE of Tennessee, Re... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["O’BRIEN", "REID", "DROWOTA", "DAUGHTREY", "ANDERSON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "REID", "dissenters": ["ANDERSON", "DAUGHTREY"], "vote": "3–2", "yes": ["DROWOTA", "O’BRIEN"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:9994310|9994381 |
cap_panel_vote-3f107cd155cde9b1 | Question: Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly. The text includes the beginning of each opinion filed in the case, in printed order; [...] shows where text was left out.
Answer these in order.
1. Did DAUGHTREY vote with the majority opinion?
2. Name any dissenting judges.
---
Betty J. PHILLIPS, ... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["O’BRIEN", "ANDERSON", "DROWOTA", "DAUGHTREY", "REID"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "ANDERSON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["DAUGHTREY", "DROWOTA", "O’BRIEN", "REID"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "p... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:9994310|9994381 |
cap_panel_vote-9cd0f5aecfbf71cf | <|start|><|user|>
Answer using the case text that follows. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
"""
18287
In re ESTATE of William L. OUZTS, Wilmot B. Ouzts, as Administrator d. b. n. c. t. a. of the Estate of William L. Ouzts, Petitioner-Respon... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sc | Supreme Court of South Carolina | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "4–1", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["Brailsford", "Taylor", "Moss", "Bussey", "Lewis"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "Moss", "dissenters": ["Bussey"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["Lewis", "Taylor"], "types": ["majority", "concurrence", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind":... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:2110595|2110517 |
cap_panel_vote-980805f189c4dd34 | Task: Answer the question about the panel, using only the text provided. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Give the vote of the court (for–against).
---
18318
Fred BRATCHER, S. S. Smith, E. E. Cowan, W. M. Tripp, J. W. Cowan, P. L. Black,... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sc | Supreme Court of South Carolina | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "5–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["Brailsford", "Taylor", "Moss", "Bussey", "Lewis"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "Taylor", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["Brailsford", "Bussey", "Lewis", "Moss"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_vote",... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:2110595|2110517 |
cap_panel_vote-6cf6cf9cd4422dd8 | <|start|><|user|>
Below are the head matter and the opening of each opinion in a reported case. Answer the question. The passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case, in the order printed; [...] marks omitted text.
Was MERRILL part of the majority?
Excerpt:
164 So.2d 498
Virginia MASSEY v. Emmett MASSEY... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:ala | Alabama Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["COLEMAN", "MERRILL", "GOODWYN", "LIVINGSTON", "LAWSON", "SIMPSON", "HARWOOD"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": null, "dissenters": ["SIMPSON"], "vote": "6–1", "yes": ["COLEMAN", "GOODWYN", "HARWOOD", "LAWSON", "LIVINGSTON", "MERRIL... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:2605704|2604461 |
cap_panel_vote-acd750d0805978e0 | You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...].
---
162 So.2d 616
Edgar Lowell HARDIN v. STATE of Alabama.
6 Div. 36.
Supreme Court of Alabama.... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:ala | Alabama Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["COLEMAN", "GOODWYN", "LIVINGSTON", "LAWSON", "JJT"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "LAWSON", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["COLEMAN", "GOODWYN", "JJT", "LIVINGSTON"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_jo... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:2605704|2604461 |
cap_panel_vote-331139dfe13c8277 | Query: Answer the question about the opinions filed in this case and the judges who decided it. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...]. Do not use outside knowledge of the court.
Questions:
1. How did the judges divide? Give the vote as a count,... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "3–2", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["ROBERTS-", "LEEDOM", "RUDOLPH", "SMITH", "SICKEL"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "RUDOLPH", "dissenters": ["ROBERTS-", "SMITH"], "vote": "3–2", "yes": ["LEEDOM"], "types": ["majority", "concurrence", "dissent"], "questions": [{"... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:4684340|4681789 |
cap_panel_vote-17fc507ad362e5ad | Read the excerpts from this appellate decision and answer the question about the judges. Each opinion filed in the case is shown from its start, in the order printed, and cut text is marked [...].
How did the judges divide? Give the vote as a count, e.g. majority–minority.
---
DAVIES et al., Respondents v. TOMS et al... | cap_panel_vote | pv_vote | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_vote", "anchor_answer": "5–0", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["ROBERTS", "LEEDOM", "RUDOLPH", "SMITH", "SICKEL"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "LEEDOM", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["ROBERTS", "RUDOLPH", "SICKEL"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_vote", "q": "Ho... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:4684340|4681789 |
cap_panel_vote-d420d3ebe7ffbb66 | <|start|><|user|>
You are given the head matter and the first part of each opinion in a case. Answer as briefly as possible. Every opinion filed in this case is represented below by its opening, in printed order, with omissions marked [...]. Give surnames as they are printed.
Did STEWART side with the majority?
Passa... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:p2d | Utah Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "no", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["HALL", "STEWART", "MAUGHAN", "CROCKETT", "WILKINS"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "WILKINS", "dissenters": ["STEWART"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["CROCKETT", "HALL", "MAUGHAN"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_join... | chat | cap_panel_vote|pair:10457796|10457936 |
cap_panel_vote-07da354d8a58dbdd | From the court record below, determine the answer. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Excerpt:
TRIANGLE OIL, INC., a corporation, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. NORTH SALT LAKE CORPORATION et al., Defendants and Respondents.
No. 16269.
Supreme... | cap_panel_vote | pv_join | cap:p2d | Utah Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "pv_join", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": true, "panel": ["HALL", "STEWART", "MAUGHAN", "CROCKETT", "WILKINS"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "CROCKETT", "dissenters": [], "vote": "5–0", "yes": ["HALL", "MAUGHAN", "STEWART", "WILKINS"], "types": ["majority"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv_jo... | plain | cap_panel_vote|pair:10457796|10457936 |
cap_panel_vote-0eda12468cce4d88 | Request: Question about the judges in an appellate case. The relevant text is below. All opinions in the case appear below (each one's beginning, in the order printed); omitted text is marked [...].
Excerpt:
387 P.2d 860
Kenneth D. SENDER, Petitioner, v. Honorable Samuel Z. MONTOYA, Judge of Division I of the District... | cap_panel_vote | pv_any | cap:nm | Supreme Court of New Mexico | {"anchor_kind": "pv_any", "anchor_answer": "yes", "unanimous": false, "panel": ["NOBLE", "MOISE", "CHAVEZ", "CARMODY", "COMPTON"], "panel_src": "concur_lines", "author": "CARMODY", "dissenters": ["NOBLE"], "vote": "4–1", "yes": ["CHAVEZ", "COMPTON", "MOISE"], "types": ["majority", "dissent"], "questions": [{"kind": "pv... | qa | cap_panel_vote|pair:5320308|5321972 |
ALEA CAP Panel Vote
Reading questions about who decided an appellate case and how the judges voted, asked over excerpts of published American appellate decisions. Each document shows the head matter of a case and the beginning of every opinion filed in it (majority, concurrences, dissents) in the order printed. It also shows the printed lines that record each judge's position, such as "SMITH and JONES, JJ., concur." and "BROWN, J., dissents.".
Question types:
- Did any judge dissent?
- Which judges dissented? (listed in printed order)
- What was the vote (for example 2–1, 5–2, 3–0)?
- Did judge X join the majority opinion?
- Who wrote a separate concurring opinion? (rare)
- Who wrote the opinion of the court? (rare)
Answers are short (a surname as printed, Yes / No, a vote count) or one plain sentence.
Revision (2026-11-21): row drops from a yes / no label-balance audit
An audit of yes / no training rows across ALEA task sets removed a small number of rows from this release:
- rows were removed so that every prompt layout and wording with at least 50 rows has a yes share between 40% and 60%.
| file | rows before | rows after | tokens before | tokens after |
|---|---|---|---|---|
data/train-00000-of-00001.parquet |
4,620 | 4,609 | - | - |
Whole rows were removed; no text was edited, and every remaining row is byte-identical to the previous release. Earlier versions remain in the dataset history. Counts elsewhere in this card describe the previous release unless restated here.
Source
The cases come from the Caselaw Access Project opinions in the KL3M public-record case-law collection (court decisions are
public record). Passages are whole verbatim pieces of one case, in printed order, and a line [...] marks omitted text. Every
document states once that the passage shows the start of every opinion filed in the case.
How the answers were derived
All answers are deterministic, from the opinion types and authors recorded for each case and a detect-only parse of the printed judges' lines. No language model was used.
Participation evidence. A case is used only when the shown text accounts for every judge on the panel other than the author: each must be named on a printed concur, dissent or join line. Unanimity and joining are never inferred from silence.
Vote convention. The vote is (judges voting for the judgment) – (dissenters plus judges who join a dissent). A judge who concurs, including one who concurs only in the result, counts with the majority.
"Did X join the majority opinion?" This is asked only about majority members who joined the opinion of the court ("Yes") and about dissenters and dissent joiners ("No"). It is never asked about a judge who concurs in the result only, or who writes or joins a separate concurrence.
What was left out
Cases are dropped when:
- there is a partial dissent ("in part"), or a judge took no part;
- a judge sat by designation or pro tempore;
- two judges share a surname;
- the panel size is not 3, 5, 7 or 9;
- a judges' line cannot be parsed;
- a judge's position is stated in the text but not accounted for (for example "with whom X joins" in a dissent heading);
- a dissenter writes that they concur with the majority on all issues but one, which drops the join question for that judge.
Cases already used by earlier ALEA case-law datasets were also excluded.
Pairing. Each case with a dissent is paired with a unanimous case from the same court and era, often the same volume and panel. The pair is asked the same question. Some unanimous cases mention a dissent by a judge outside the panel (in a citation); these are kept as hard cases.
Composition
| documents | 4,620 |
| tokens | 2,378,574 (alea-v2b-sw32k tokenizer, with document boundary tokens) |
| presentations | plain 41%, question-answer frame 30%, chat 29% |
| question types (anchor) | join 32%, vote 23%, dissenters 23%, any dissent 19%, author 3% |
| answer balance | any dissent yes/no 49/51; joined the majority yes/no 52/48 |
| no-dissent answers | 51% of all dissent, vote and any-dissent questions |
| largest court | 4.9% of documents; no court above 5% |
Question-only baselines. These sit at or below the majority-class prior.
Known limits
- The author of the opinion of the court is always the first opinion printed, so author questions are kept to about 2% of all questions.
- Questions with a named concurrence author are rare. Most concurrence questions are answered "None".
- Requiring participation evidence excludes most federal-circuit cases, which list the panel only in a "Before" line. The set is therefore smaller and weighted toward state appellate courts.
Columns
| column | content |
|---|---|
id |
row identifier |
text |
the full rendered training document |
family |
cap_panel_vote |
kind |
the anchor question type: pv_join, pv_vote, pv_dissent, pv_any, pv_author or pv_concur |
source |
cap:<reporter> |
court |
the deciding court |
gold |
JSON string: panel, author, dissenters, vote, and per-question answers |
presentation |
plain, qa or chat |
group_id |
shared by paired documents |
Decontamination
Rows were screened with word n-gram rules against evaluation benchmarks, evaluation probes and held-out sets of related datasets. Only real item or passage overlap was dropped (about 4% of candidate rows); overlaps limited to legal boilerplate were kept.
Review
Each round had rendered documents checked by hand against their passages, and 60 randomly drawn documents read by an independent blind reviewer.
First round: 2 of 60 wrong. Both were exact full-bench votes and "joined" answers on benches whose shown text named no concurring judges. A further class of minor issues inferred unanimity from silence.
Fixes before the second round:
- the participation-evidence rule;
- the statement on every document that all opinions are shown;
[...]at every cut;- a cap on author questions.
Second round: 0 of 60 wrong. The remaining minor issues were fixed: a doubled scope sentence, and dissenters now listed in printed order.
License
CC BY 4.0.
- Downloads last month
- 79